A practical acceptance checklist for an AI pilot
By TechDriven Solutions · · 2 min read
Define a narrow task, evaluation set, permission boundary, failure path, and operating assumptions before expanding an AI prototype.
The decision to make
A pilot should produce evidence about a task. Keep access limited, test failures, and decide in advance what would justify a wider release.
Start with a task and a simpler baseline
An AI pilot is easier to judge when it answers a concrete question: can it classify incoming requests, find an approved passage, or draft a response for a person to review? 'Build an intelligent agent' leaves the evaluator with no useful acceptance boundary.
Write down how the task is done today and consider whether search, a rule, or a conventional form would solve it. The objective is a better workflow, not a particular architecture. Keep actions that affect customers or records outside an exploratory demo unless their controls are explicitly in scope.
Build a small but representative review set
Choose anonymized examples that cover ordinary work, missing information, ambiguous input, and cases where the system should decline. Keep the expected result or scoring rule separate from the input so reviewers can judge a new approach consistently.
For an illustrative support-drafting task, a useful review asks whether the answer uses an approved source, invents a policy, reveals another user's data, or needs escalation. Score those dimensions separately; an average score can hide a serious permission failure.
- Define what counts as correct, incomplete, and unsafe to use.
- Include cases that the system cannot answer from available information.
- Record the prompt, data, and configuration used in each comparison.
- Review failures before increasing the feature's permissions.
Treat retrieved content and tools as separate boundaries
Text found in a document should not be allowed to change the application's permissions. Decide which sources the user may access and what each tool may do. A read-only prototype is a useful first boundary; consequential writes need an explicit approval design.
OWASP identifies risks around prompt injection and excessive agency in LLM applications. A useful response is to restrict actions, validate tool inputs, and keep authorization in application code. A sentence telling the model to behave safely is not a substitute for those controls.
Agree what would justify a production phase
Measure the task's useful result, reviewer correction effort, latency, and usage cost under the pilot assumptions. Include provider limits, data processing terms, retention, and ongoing evaluation in the production discussion. These are deployment decisions, not details a chat interface settles automatically.
Define a stop condition. If the prototype cannot meet the task's threshold or still requires more review than the original process, simplify or stop it. A pilot that prevents an unsuitable rollout is useful work even when it does not become a larger build.
Primary references
Official documentation for the technical principles discussed above. Check the documentation that matches your application when planning implementation.
Continue with your scope
Have a task to discuss?
Send the workflow, current system, and constraints. An anonymized example is enough to begin a scope conversation.
Discuss the work